—
Stated attributes
Publicly stated commitments — not necessarily independently verified.
Independent ratingsBrands can’t pay to change themHow we rate
TOMS is a B Corp-certified footwear brand known for its philanthropic giving model, pledging one-third of profits to nonprofits supporting children's education, health, and well-being. The brand uses sustainable materials like recycled cotton, polyester, and rubber in its Earthwise collection, with a stated goal to source 100% sustainable cotton by 2025. However, TOMS faces significant gaps in environmental accountability—it has not published a complete carbon footprint (citing 2021 supply chain pressures) and lacks documented water reduction or textile waste programs. On labor practices, while TOMS conducts unannounced factory audits and works with Fair Labor Association members, manufacturing occurs in countries with elevated labor abuse risk, and there is no public evidence of living wage verification for factory workers.
Three pillars, scored independently. Higher is better.
Reports and allegations from named sources, linked so you can read them yourself. Being listed here doesn’t mean a claim is proven.
TOMS faced sustained criticism from development experts that its original One-for-One donation model was unsustainable, created economic dependency in recipient communities, and could undermine local businesses. In 2020, after 14 years and 100 million pairs donated, TOMS retired the model in favor of pledging one-third of profits to charitable causes, citing financial unsustainability.
Multiple independent analysts have noted that TOMS sources from countries with extreme labor abuse risk (China, Vietnam, India) but provides no public evidence of living wage verification or documented worker empowerment programs, despite B Corp certification.
TOMS set a goal to source 100% sustainable cotton by 2025 but has abandoned this target. Additionally, the company admitted in 2021 that it could not complete a full carbon footprint assessment due to supply chain pressures, and no comprehensive carbon data has since been published.
6 products from TOMS, sold on Amazon (US). Leif earns a commission on qualifying purchases.